Overall I enjoyed this cruise experience.
Some things I really enjoyed about the Carnival Liberty were:
1) The inside stateroom (8250) was plenty roomy enough and everything worked as it should. Some newer ships have much smaller inside rooms, but on the Liberty it was a perfect size. Not cramped for 2 adults. I also like that you can order a 12 pack of water prior to the cruise for a reasonable price and it is delivered to your stateroom. Other cruise lines rip you off for water, but carnival keeps the price fair. Our stateroom steward Pedro did an excellent job and was always cheerful. Really enjoyed having him take care of us!
This cabin was good. Everything worked as it should, and it had plenty of room and plenty of places to store clothes / other items. The safe was an okay size. Bathroom was nicely laid out with enough room. We were inbetween two other stateroom decks so it was quiet.
Beds felt a little strange to lay on, but it was okay for me to sleep on.
Out stateroom steward Pedro did an excellent job and was always cheerful. Really enjoyed having him look after our room.