This was are ninth cruise with DCL. Have sailed on all 4 ships. Had not sailed on the Magic or Wonder in a long time and I had forgotten how nice they are! The Magic was in great shape, has a new water slide and a new restaurant. Rapunzel's. The food and service was excellent in all 3 dining rooms. Rapunzel's has an interactive dinner show that was fun. The Dining rooms on the classic ships are less crowded then on the Dream class. In fact it did not seem crowded in any of the public areas. Entertainment from shows to trivia in pubs was all excellent. Did not do any excursions, did are own walking tours of Key West and Nassau. Castaway Cay as usual was great and again less crowded with the smaller ship. Would not hesitate to book on the Magic! I also booked a placeholder on board for a future cruise that will give us 10% off plus 100.00 credit.
First time trying a Navigators balcony, it was fine for a short cruise and for just us two. Balcony is smaller. And private. We were aft and heard some engine noise when docking, Also right above Animators Palette and heard some noise during dinner. Still got the balcony experience and saved money by booking this cabin