Travel agent had cruised Liberty in advance.Personal acquaintance & trusted her recommendation.1st day-exciting on the Lido deck. Nono & the staff-great job.Kids loved Guy’s burgers.Our room was inside-due to motion sickness.No complaints at all.Herald was our contact if we needed anything & was superb.Cleanliness-excellent.Could smell sulfur water in halls from time to time.Not a problem smells like Fla.Dining rooms-really nice.Buffet had many choices for our very picky G-son.Food on the deck-very good. Kids loved ice cream-no toppings.I enjoyed deli for light meal.Desserts-good.I tried things new to me-no disappointments.Moving around the ship took some research.Get familiar with how the decks work ahead of time.Nassau excursion-excellent.4 hr tour-got what we paid for. Entertainment was available for all ages. Son & fiancé went on the swim with dolphins, stingrays, seals etc. If it’s in your budget they highly recommend.Coffee-no complaints(dark roast).No pressure to buy cocktails.All staff was excellent.Embark/debark easy w/staggered times. So glad I did not take all the negative reviews at face value. I know things happen. I am ok with accidents as long as things get rectified. We had no requests not met. Room service-on time & as requested. Kids enjoyed the pools & poolside lounging.We all enjoyed Bingo, even won. Not fond of all the cigarette smoke in the casino area. Did not go in the shops on board. A little pushy to make jewelry sales so I never went inside so I could keep walking. If the prices were good deals I will never know since I am not comfortable with aggressive sales people. Some passengers don’t make it easy for the staff. People would just leave dishes & food in places that I would not have. That’s just me. IE: dishes at elevators where someone could trip over them, sat unfinished ice cream cones to melt where people would step in. Staff was quickly cleaning up those types of things! Breakfast buffet was overwhelming! So many great choices. Had some good chats with strangers. Our son, daughter-in-law & grands did the Segway excursion & had a blast. Kids enjoyed the pizza in the evening. I would do it all over again!