The Carnival Liberty was swapped with the Valor prior to my cruise the stops were identical. We skipped St. Kitts and went to Antigua and it was lovely the staff was very helpful switching out our excursion to the new port. The ship was great the staff was amazing loved the cruise director and assistant cruise director. My only negative was I did not like the American Table menu as much as the old one. Might just be me I was raised by a picky eaters so I tend to be more finicky than most. I found something every night to eat but it was difficult some times. I would recommend this ship and the current ports of call. The only other negative was many nights there was no one preforming in the piano bar and it was a lovely space that seemed wasted. Not sure if they had no one on board to preform or if this is a standard schedule just the last few days of the trip.